"2034" Co-Authors Break Down Warfare Scenes From Film & TV
Released on 03/10/2021
I am dangerous.
I've made a decision. Fire one.
Incoming!
Hi, my name is Elliot Ackerman.
Hi, I'm Admiral Jim Stavridis.
[Narrator] Elliot and Admiral Stavridis
are the coauthors of 2034,
a new novel imagining the next World War.
Today we'll be reviewing clips of TV and film
that feature themes represented in our book, 2034.
Surprise attack, Midway.
Incoming!
[bullets firing]
What you have just seen is the worst day
in the history of the United States Navy.
[airplanes buzzing]
Pearl Harbor was viewed, at the time of the attack,
as not vulnerable to the Japanese Navy.
Their attack was a master stroke, tactically.
Pearl is under attack
and we don't even know if the bastards are north or south?
It fundamentally changed our approach
to deep intelligence, imagining what could happen.
We're gonna place our bet right there.
We now work together jointly,
Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps.
We are fairly seamless in sharing information.
That was not the case prior to the second World War.
[typewriter tapping]
One of the greatest takeaways from this scene
is that it was the result of a failure in US imagination.
And so it's incumbent on us,
you could even say it's a national security priority,
that we be actively imagining the threats
that will come to us in the future.
Be prepared for anything.
Miscommunication-- Actually.
This one is mine.
I can do it.
Miscommunication, The Bedford Incident.
All systems are in the ready.
This is insane! Ah don't worry Commodore,
The Bedford will never fire first.
But if he fires one I'll fire one.
Fire one.
This scene from The Bedford Incident
is famous throughout the Navy,
where the commanding officer
seeks simply to arm the missile.
Arm number one, ASROC.
But the junior officer...
Aye-aye, sir.
Mistakes his words, and actually launches the missile.
If he fires one, I'll fire one.
Fire one.
It is possible that this could happen.
Geez! [missile booms]
And as a result, that firing chain of command in the Navy
is typically guarded in a two person way,
similar to that with nuclear weapons.
Probably the most similar incident occurred in 1988.
When the USS Vincennes, a cruiser, tragically,
mistakenly shot down an Iranian commercial aircraft.
Killing hundreds of innocent civilians.
It's an example of in the tension of combat
terrible and tragic mistakes can be made.
This was one.
Loss of humanity, Full Metal Jacket.
[gun firing]
Get some, get some, yeah!
In this scene, we see a helicopter door gunner
shooting at unarmed Vietnamese civilians.
[Soldier] Get some, get some, yeah, yeah, yeah!
Full Metal Jacket, which was directed by
Stanley Kubrick, was in part written by
Vietnam War correspondent Michael Herr.
And Michael Herr's iconic book, Dispatches,
has this exact scene.
Why should we do a story about you?
'Cause I'm so [beeps] good.
The portrait of this door gunner
firing at the Vietnamese civilians,
and specifically that bit of dialogue, get some.
Get some!
In Marine circles to this day,
kind of is a slang for like,
you're gonna go out and do the most extreme thing
you can imagine, you're gonna go get some.
Anyone who runs is a VC.
Anyone who stands still is a well disciplined VC. [laughs]
Oftentimes, to wage war, we need to dehumanize our enemy.
How can you shoot women, children?
And that dehumanization is also as old as war itself.
You just don't lead 'em so much.
The military theoretician Clausewitz said,
The nature of war is slaughter.
That has always been the case,
and I believe that always will remain the case.
Just keeping it light. [laughs]
Stealth technology, The Hunt for Red October.
[Man] What are these doors?
You don't miss much, do you?
In this scene, CIA analyst Jack Ryan
uncovers the Russian's latest technological advancement.
This could be a caterpillar. A what?
Magneto hydrodynamic propulsion, you follow?
No.
The caterpillar drive is a fictitious propulsion system
used on the Red October.
It's like a jet engine for the water.
Goes in the front, gets squirted out the back.
So the propulsion system is virtually silent,
which drastically reduces the seismic signature
of the submarine, making it very, very difficult to detect.
Let me take this.
It's the acoustic signature, not a seismic signature.
Sorry.
[Jim] I don't know if that's important.
[Man] Who let you in here?
The caterpillar drive system
from The Hunt for Red October
doesn't exist at that level of capability in real life.
We messed with this a couple years ago.
We couldn't make it work.
But the idea of using water propulsion systems
to silence submarines is quite real.
It's doubtful our sonar'd even pick it up.
And if it did, it'd sound like whales humping,
or some kind of seismic anomaly, anything but a submarine.
What caught our attention in this scene,
and thinking about 2034,
is that you never know when your opponent
is going to suddenly make a technological leap
that renders you highly vulnerable.
This thing could park a couple a hundred warheads
off Washington or New York, and no one would know
anything about it 'til it was all over.
Emerging tech, Black Mirror.
[man yelling] [alarm blaring]
[glass crashes]
So in this episode we see autonomous dog-like
military robots turning on humanity.
[man yelling]
In these scenes when you see drones turning on people
it's not necessarily too far-fetched.
'Cause that technology is being developed
and it wouldn't take much to weaponize that technology.
[beeps]
Currently, the US military views this technology
as something that it's essential
that there is a human decision maker in the loop.
However, it's very easy to imagine a scenario
where other countries don't feel
those same ethical inhibitions,
which would be, quite frankly, chilling.
What kind of society is that?
Cybersecurity phones hack, Mr. Robot.
I've been lying to you.
I don't take my pills, but you don't either.
In this scene, Elliot reveals
that he's hacked his psychologist.
I don't just hack you Krista, I hack everyone.
My friends, coworkers.
There are 7 billion people on the planet today
and probably 40 billion devices connected to the internet.
Every one of those devices is a potential attack surface.
On paper, your Thursday 2:00,
Marilyn O'Brien, is your doppelganger.
As advanced as your technology becomes
it can also become a weakness
because your over-reliance on it makes you vulnerable.
You bought a tall hazelnut latte,
paid for it on your Evil Corp card.
We've certainly seen the reliance
we all place on our phoness, on the internet.
If a competitor nation can shut down your cyber capability,
suddenly a high-tech war can immediately
turn into a very, very low tech war.
Cybersecurity is at the top of the worry list
for the Pentagon.
All of our systems depend on
internet-like communication paths.
I sometimes watch you on your webcam.
You cry sometimes.
Just like me.
Cyber security requires over time
the creation of a cyber force,
if we're gonna be prepared
for the coming conflict in cyberspace.
Really good advice.
False commands, Dr. Strangelove.
[machine buzzing]
In this scene, a patrolling bomber
is given a wrongful command to drop a hydrogen bomb.
I know you'll think this is crazy,
but I just got a message from base over the CRM114,
it decodes as wing attack plan R, Alpha Romeo.
There certainly has never been a false command
to actually launch a nuclear strike against an enemy.
How many times have I told you guys
that I don't want no horsing around on the airplane?
All of our nuclear codes are held at the highest levels.
No single actor has access to
our nuclear weapons or nuclear codes.
I'm not horsing around, sir.
That's how it decodes.
One of the things that I love about that scene
and how it's constructed is you're seeing this very real
and premeditated architecture of the codes.
But you're also seeing it overlaid
in a very realistic and human situation.
Major Kong, is it possible
this is some kind of loyalty test?
You know, give the go code and then recall
to see who would actually go?
It is 100% likely that individuals receiving the code
would stop, question, think about it.
Oh there's just gotta be something wrong.
But ultimately, if the order was legitimate,
and had come through the nuclear channels properly,
it would be executed.
Well, boys, I reckon this is it.
The American service member, Top Gun.
You guys really are cowboys.
What's your problem, Kazansky?
We see in this clip, the sort of...
I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you.
Classic...
[man howling]
20th century... I want some butts!
Machismo.
[Kazansky] I don't like you because you're dangerous.
That's right.
They're as much attacking each other
as bonding with each other.
I am dangerous.
In the novel 2034 culture plays a very important role,
as it does in all conflict.
He's laughing at us.
No it's me laughing, dickhead.
That type of interaction...
Well, you shut up.
Don't worry. Okay I won't.
Just don't worry.
Although over the top,
I think is and continues to be accurate.
And it's something we wanted to harness
and put into the book.
Remember boys, no points for second place.
The Naval hijacking, Operation Red Sea.
[man speaking in a foreign language]
An attack by pirates in certain shipping lanes
around the world is highly likely.
[suspenseful music]
Both the US and the Chinese armed forces
train for hostage scenarioses
because such scenarioses are all too real.
[gun firing] [glass shattering]
One of the things the clip doesn't really
emphasize properly is the extent to which
a rescue force would prioritize
the safety of those hostages.
The idea of taking a shot like the one you just saw
is probably pretty unrealistic
given the threat that would pose
to the individuals that'd been taken hostage.
Sudden escalation, Hunter Killer.
In this clip, we see a US submarine
that thinks it's undetectable being hit by a Russian sub.
Stay right behind her.
This scenario is all too likely.
Our submarines are operating under the Arctic ice,
monitoring Russian subsurface activity.
What you see here is an Akula Class Russian submarine,
the very best and quietest of their nuclear attack boats.
What is that?
It's crucial that the United States Navy
have accurate acoustic information
about each one of the Russian submarines.
Torpedo in the water, bearing 335 at 600 yards.
Torpedo evasion.
If we were to go into a combat situation
we would know the submarines we were up against.
All ahead flanked. There's no time.
200 yards. Right hard rudder.
Terminal holding!
[missile whooshing]
[explosion booming]
It's unlikely there would be a sudden attack like that
under current geopolitical circumstances.
15 years from now,
what are the relations between the United States and Russia?
What are the relations between the United States and China?
That's really the premise that we explore in 2034.
War room briefing, The Hunt for Red October.
You son of a bitch.
You son of a bitch!
Jack Ryan realizes that the Russian captain is defecting.
Ramius might be trying to defect.
Do you mean to suggest that this man has come--
Proceed.
So often, history hinges on the little people,
the medium sized bureaucrats who speak up in a meeting
and are told to act on their opinions.
You're just an analyst.
What can you possibly know what goes on in his mind?
I know Ramius, General.
One of the things that is somewhat realistic about this
is the ability that those mid-level officials
can have to sway opinion in a room.
Proceed, Mr. Ryan.
It's not necessarily that they're choosing to
believe Jack Ryan over the Admiral,
but they're giving him an opportunity
to prove that he's right.
Let's assume for a minute that you're right
and this Russian intends to defect.
What do you suggest we do about it?
In 2034 we have a character
who's very similar to Jack Ryan,
in that he's often in the room
where decisions are being made.
And there are a few critical times in the book,
speaks up in ways that proved to be extremely influential.
I said speak your mind, Jack, but Jesus.
Cloaking device, Star Trek.
Throw the switch.
[dramatic music]
Weapons officer, commence fire--
They have the cloaking device!
This does not really exist.
Although as we move forward in time,
and stealth becomes better and better,
it is not inconceivable that extremely large vessels
could, at some point, evade detection.
Cloaking device is working perfectly.
At this moment, for example, a large US Navy destroyer,
something that is 10,000 tons and 500 feet in length,
can appear on a radar to be as small
as a coastal fishing boat.
But it doesn't completely disappear, yet.
Captain, I'm working as fast as I can!
Crisis call, Dr. Strangelove.
You know how we've always talked about
the possibility of something going wrong with a bomb.
The US president calls the Russians,
trying to smooth over an attack
One of our base commanders, he had a sort of,
well, he went a little funny in the head.
Countries communicate best
when the leadership simply picks up the phones.
Of course, I like to say hello.
When they are in that intimate space, one-on-one.
Well it's good that you're fine then, and I'm fine.
They can be very candid
and they can find their way to real agreement.
[President] I agree with you, it's great to be fine.
But too often leaders are bound by
talking points prepared by their staffs
and they don't have a true human conversation.
I am as sorry as you are Dimitri,
don't say that you're more sorry than I am,
because I'm capable of being just as sorry as you are.
And it therefore becomes very difficult
to resolve situations in crisis.
Dimitri, there's no point in you getting hysterical
at a moment like this!
Close call, Hunter Killer.
Launch detection, reports 15 seconds to impact, sir.
Locked on enemy missiles, sir.
The US submarine is attacked by the Russians.
Intercept window closed. Impact!
There is no point in ducking when you're
on a ship and there are missiles inbound.
[missiles whooshing]
What just happened?
Often audiences think that all these operations
go very, very smoothly.
You've had to make a call like this before, Captain?
I've never been part of a real world operation
where I actually knew...
Who fired? Not us.
Everything that was happening.
And this scene, I think is a perfect example
of that kind of confusion.
Commander, did you know? I didn't.
I hoped.
Breaking rank, Crimson Tide.
Repeat my command.
Sir, we don't know what this message means.
Our target package could have changed.
You repeat this order
or I'll find somebody who will!
We see the second in command refusing to launch
the attack that his commanding officer is ordering.
I do not concur.
And I do not recognize your authority to relieve me
of the command under Navy regulations.
Cob, arrest this man and get him out of here!
The scenario depicted in Crimson Tide
is highly unlikely.
It's based on a partially received order
to launch the nuclear weapons.
Our systems have many fail-safes built into them
to ensure that those orders come through clearly.
You of command, Captain.
I order you to place under arrest on the charge of mutiny!
There has not been a charge of mutiny
laid in the United States Navy since the 19th century.
I've made a decision, I'm captain of this boat.
Now shut the [beeps] up!
I think it's hard to put yourself
in the shoes of a captain and an executive officer
with a partially received nuclear launch.
So I don't think anybody is actually
overreacting in this scenario.
Captain please. Now, Cob!
How wars end, 1917.
There is only one way this war ends.
Last man standing.
Colonel Mackenzie is talking about
the nature of the first World War,
and potentially war itself.
And when he says... Last man standing.
I think what he's alluding to is this only ends
once one side has had its will totally and utterly broken.
And that's always been the case with war.
I have heard it all before.
I think the larger question is not necessarily
how do wars end, but why do wars persist?
Well done, lad.
Thank you, sir.
Conclusion. In addition to
enjoying a good story, what we hope people
will take away from the novel 2034
is some more active engagement with some of the challenges
that are facing our country as we move forwards.
Okay, Elliot, you got the con,
as we say in the Navy Marine Corps team.
All right, see ya, Jim.
Thanks, Wired.
[people clapping and cheering]
Movie Accent Expert Breaks Down Actors Playing Real People
Accent Expert Breaks Down 6 Fictional Languages From Film & TV
Movie Accent Expert Breaks Down Actors' Accents
Surgical Resident Breaks Down Medical Scenes From Film & TV
Forensics Expert Examines Crime Scene Investigations From Film & TV
Movie Accent Expert Breaks Down 28 More Actors' Accents
Lawyer Breaks Down Courtroom Scenes From Film & TV
Former CIA Chief of Disguise Breaks Down Spy Scenes From Film & TV
Surgical Resident Breaks Down More Medical Scenes From Film & TV
Movie Accent Expert Breaks Down Actors Playing Presidents
Accent Expert Breaks Down 17 More Actors Playing Real People
Forensics Expert Examines 25 More Crime Scene Investigations From Film & TV
Pro Driver Breaks Down Driving Scenes From Film & TV
Disease Expert Breaks Down Pandemic Scenes From Film & TV
NASA Astronaut Breaks Down Space Scenes From Film & TV
Surgeon Breaks Down 22 Medical Scenes From Film & TV
Pro Driver Breaks Down More Driving Scenes From Film & TV
Lawyer Breaks Down 17 More Courtroom Scenes From Film & TV
Robotics Expert Breaks Down Robot Scenes From Film & TV
NASA Astronaut Breaks Down More Space Scenes From Film & TV
Robotics Expert Breaks Down More Robot Scenes From Film & TV
Physics Expert Breaks Down Superhero Physics From Film & TV
Airline Pilot Breaks Down Flying Scenes From Film & TV
Fight Master Breaks Down Sword Fighting From Film & TV
Former US Air Force Fighter Pilot Breaks Down 12 Fighter Pilot Scenes From Film & TV
Retired FBI Agent Breaks Down Surveillance Scenes From Film & TV
Conductor Breaks Down Orchestra Scenes From Film & TV
Hacker Breaks Down Hacking Scenes From Movies & TV
Former Army Intel Director Breaks Down Spy Satellite Scenes From Movies & TV
Surgeon Breaks Down 16 Medical Scenes From Film & TV
Bug Expert Breaks Down Bug Scenes From Movies & TV
Mortician Breaks Down Dead Body Scenes From Movies & TV
Aquanaut Breaks Down Ocean Exploration Scenes From Movies & TV
Chemist Breaks Down 22 Chemistry Scenes From Movies & TV
Military Historian Breaks Down Medievals Weapons in Video Games
Hacker Breaks Down 26 Hacking Scenes From Movies & TV
"2034" Co-Authors Break Down Warfare Scenes From Film & TV